2009 Broadband Card Comparison

For the most recent info, check out the 2010 Broadband Card Comparison

broadband-race-2

Just like last year, all this talk of aircards and broadband cards is like trying to tell the difference between cabbage and lettuce blind-folded.

Seriously.

How about concise quality facts and more information only if you ask for it eh?

I know how you feel. I’ve tried Googling ‘compare aircards’ and ‘aircard reviews’ too. Tough stuff to find.

*N.B. If this stuff is like a foreign language to you, I suggest reading going through the “Wireless Broadband Exposed” mini-course.

That why I list all the aircards on the market .

There are 3 categories (USB, ExpressCards and PC Broadband Cards). Each gets compared side-by-side. See which card fits your needs based on:
1. Network
2. Speed
3. Operating System Compatibility
4. Extra Features
5. Price
To sweeten the honey even further, you can click on any card to read the full review and technical specifications. Let’s hop right to it.

image

Network & Speed

There are more USB broadband cards out there than any other type. Naturally, Sprint has the most as they’ve been in the mobile broadband game longer. The capabilities of the cards are pretty much on par across the board with the exception of AT&T.
Being the only GSM gang in town, they don’t get to work up roaming agreements with other carriers. While that is a valid excuse for their coverage being less than Sprint, Verizon’s and Alltel, they are rapidly expanding and upgrading. You can thank the iPhone for that one.
Thanks to their HSPA technology they’ve got the potential for 14.4 Mbps download speeds. That’s literally a cable connection on the go. At this point, its the only 3G technology that could give WiMAX a run for it’s money until the other carriers upgrade to EVDO Rev. B or LTE.

Compatibility & Extra Features

When it comes to operating system support, most USB cards work with Windows and Macintosh. While some may not advertise native support for Linux, there are those that explicitly market their compatibility with pretty much all. For more details on specific cards, check out the individual broadband card reviews.

Extra features like expandable storage and GPS are what set USB broadband cards apart from each other. About half of the cards featured here have microSD slots for expandable storage. Pretty neat since they also work with most cell phones.

While the U680 has built-in flash storage, it’s only 64MB…that’s about one music album. No good.

The cards with expandable microSD slots support up to 32GB. That’s more than you’ll ever need for all you documents.
GPS is supported almost exclusively by Sprint mobile broadband cards.

While a few Verizon cards support it, Sprint has long included location based services at no extra charge. Definitely a plus for the savvy traveler looking to find the closest coffee shop, rental car or hotel. Nothing like not worrying about the basics after a long flight or drive.

Price

*Cough…make $100…*cough. Most of the broadband cards here are free. For the ones that aren’t, you can make money from the rebates. The companies don’t mind taking a hit if that means you’ll be a paying customer for 2 years. It’s pretty much a free for all.

And The Winner Is…


Novatel Ovation U760 (Sprint)The
Novatel Ovation U760 takes the cake here. While it doesn’t have an adjustable port, it is one of the smallest broadband cards ever made. After you throw in GPS and 32 GB of microSD storage, you’ve got the Swiss army knife of broadband cards my friend.

While some may prefer the GPS and extra storage of the Novatel Ovation U760, the UM175 also puts money in your pocket and keeps your laptop safe in small space.
Back To Top

image

Network & Speed
This time, only Sprint and Verizon even have ExpressCards available. Why is that? Well, like I mention in the Verizon and Sprint AirCard reviews, PC Broadband Cards and even ExpressCards are on the way out. As carriers try to reach a broader audience (particularly netbooks that only support USB), they’re shifting their lineup of devices.

Compatibility & Extra Features


No Linux SupportOperating system support is the same across the board. All the cards support Windows XP, Vista and Mac’s. No word on Linux. That has a lot to do with the design of the ExpressCards themselves. More on the tick-tock behind mobile broadband cards in “Wireless Broadband Exposed“.

While none of the cards have extra storage, Novatel EX720 and Sierra Wireless AC597E have GPS. Does that make them better than the other cards? Yes. Yes it does. When you’ve got the only thing going for you, it sure does.

Price
Again all the cards are free or put money in your bank account. Rebates will get you up to $50 for the Sierra Wireless AC597E Aircard with Sprint. These prices change regularly so it’s best to check it.


And The Winner Is…
Sierra Wireless AC597 ExpressCard PC/Mac Card
The Sierra Wireless AC597E wins out thanks to features. In addition to that, Sierra Wireless throws in some goodies like:

  • – Patent-pending antenna design that maximizes data performance for the fastest speed, strongest signal, and most stable connection possible
  • – High performance GPS for a quick and accurate fix on your location.
  • : Patent-pending architecture for data traffic management to ensure a consistent mobile broadband experience
  • – Plug-and-play software installation, without a CD.
  • : Advanced power control to reduce PC battery drain and optimize performance under variable network conditions
  • : Hardware design that exceeds industry specifications to deal with the rough-and-tumble reality of life on the road
  • The Sierra Wireless logo, Heart of the Wireless Machine and AirCard are registered trademarks of Sierra Wireless.
  • Empowered, Compass and AirLink are trademarks of Sierra Wireless.
  • image

    Network & Speed

    There’s a pretty even mix and matchup of providers here. Everybody’s got at least one card in here. There is one definite lesson to learn here. Not all network speeds were created equal. The slowest of the bunch is T-Mobile. They are building a faster 3G network but have no cards at the moment to run on it.
    Sprint, Verizon and Alltel lead the field in terms of speed. AT&T used to have PC Broadband Cards but only offer USB at the moment.

    Compatibility & Extra Features

    Bill Gates & Steve JobsOperating system support varies a bit. You’re good to go if you’re hanging out in the Bill Gates crowd.If you’re chillin with Steve Jobs however, you’ll need to be a bit pickier. More than half the cards support Mac’s though so no big worries. If you do decide on the Sony Ericsson GC89, you’ll have to go through a third party to get the drivers for Mac support. Ironically, it’s also the only card here with extra features.
    It connects to T-Mobile Hotspots via WiFi at no extra charge. That could prove pretty handy for Starbucks faithfuls. Outside of that, it might not be helpful enough to make up for the slower EDGE network speeds.

    Price

    There some serious differences in prices here. Everything from $110 to making $100. The obviously clear winner here is Alltel. Why would anyone pay $110 for T-Mobile’s card you ask? Well, there service is $10 cheaper each month. Over the length of the contract, that would be $240 in savings. So, how do you like your savings? Over time or all at once?

    And The Winner Is…
    Alltel Huawei EC360 Aircard
    The Huawei EC360. It’s the only card here on a network that still has unlimited mobile broadband. Besides that, it’s pretty much identical to the other cards out there.
    Back To Top

    Going for the GoldSo to sum it all up, the best card from each category was:

    Novatel Ovation U760 Best USB Broadband Card
    Novatel Ovation U760 (Sprint)

    Sierra Wireless AC597EBest ExpressCard
    Sierra Wireless AC597 ExpressCard PC/Mac Card

    Huawei EC360 – Best PC Broadband Card
    Alltel Huawei EC360 Aircard

    email

    No Comments Yet. Be The Pioneer.

    Join The Conversation