4G Comparison [Infographic] | 2011 Review

4g-comparison-2011

Since last year’s comparison, every major telecom provider has launched what they’ve chosen to call 4G.

For AT&T and T-Mobile, it’s HSPA+. For Sprint & Clear, it’s WiMAX. For Verizon (and eventually everyone else), it’s LTE.

While the technical definition of 4G changes based on who you ask, it hard to argue that each provider’s 4G speeds aren’t significantly faster than their respective 3G speeds.

As PCWorld pointed out in March:

The major wireless carriers, as a group, have increased their average download speeds for laptop-modem users by more than threefold, an apparent result of their urgent transition from 3G to 4G network technology.

PCWorld.com

Here, I compare the AT&T, Clear, Sprint, Verizon and T-Mobile’s 4G mobile broadband in an infographic based on 4 factors:

  • 4G Speed
  • 4G Coverage
  • 4G Plans
  • 4G Devices

Without further ado, here’s the 4G Mobile Broadband Comparison:

(click for an enlarged version)

4G Comparison | 2011 Mobile Broadband Review

If you liked this infographic and/or found it useful, like it on Facebook, tweet and retweet it, thumb it up on Stumble Upon, Digg it, vote it up on Reddit, email it and get the word out about it.

If you’re a blogger, feel free to repost it on your site using the following embed code.

Embed This Infographic On Your Site

 

4G Speed

By pitting data sourced from PCWorld’s extensive 4G speed tests against carriers’ advertised 4G speeds, it’s easy to see that virtually every provider (with the exception of Verizon) leave a lot to be desired.

It is important to note, however, that Verizon’s 4G network is the newest of the bunch and as such may have the lightest load thanks to fewer 4G device users (including smartphones).

As it currently stands, Verizon is the clear winner for the fastest 4G speed.

 

4G Coverage

When it comes to 4G coverage, T-Mobile’s current marketing claim of the largest 4G network holds true with 100 cities (and growing).

Next in line are Sprint & Clear with 82 cities.

While Sprint/Clear’s 4G city growth rate has slowed significantly this year, the pace may be increased thanks to a recent agreement between the two parties to settle their differences.

Next up is Verizon, who recently announced a whole slew of cities to be launched by the end of 2011 as they march towards nationwide 4G coverage by 2013.

Late to the game with HSPA+ coverage is AT&T.

With plans to also launch LTE mid-2011, expanding both networks simultaneously will require some serious capital investment.

While they are in the midst of getting approval for their acquisition of T-Mobile, they’ve got a lot on their plate.

 

4G Plans

If you’re in a WiMAX city, choosing Clear/Sprint 4G will be the way to go for unlimited mobile broadband.

However, if not, the next best option will be Verizon who offers faster speeds for the same price at the 5 GB level or $5 cheaper than T-Mobile for the more data intensive bunch at 10 GB.

While T-Mobile is upgrading their theoretical speeds to 42 Mbps from 21 Mbps in a few cities, the 4G speed section illustrates that theoretical speed isn’t translating very well into actual speeds.

Unless this changes, charging $5 more than Verizon’s 10 GB won’t be justified.

 

4G Devices

While each provider has a decent offering of 4G devices (excluding smartphones and netbooks), the mobile broadband crowd that aren’t tablet focused may find AT&T, Clear & T-Mobile’s selection to be particularly limiting when compared to Sprint and Verizon.

The difference maker?

4G mobile hotspots.

Sprint and Verizon both provide 2 recent additions to their mobile hotspot line allowing connections for anywhere between 5 and 8 devices depending on the device.

While Clear also offers a similar hotspot, that device lacks a 3G chip and thus restricts it to regional 4G coverage as opposed to expanded 3G coverage as all devices on Sprint and Verizon boast.

 

Who Should You Pick?

It all depends on what your priorities are.

If primarily interested in unlimited mobile broadband, the choice lies between Sprint & Clear providing that 4G coverage is in your city. If it is, then you could save $5 using Clear or get a richer device selection from Sprint.

If primarily interested in 4G speed, then Verizon is the clear choice with T-Mobile making promising moves to be an excellent 2nd choice and even a 1st choice if located in one of their newer 42 Mbps theoretical speed coverage areas.

If 4G coverage is the top priority, then T-Mobile will be your 1st choice followed by Sprint/Clear.

Naturally, things won’t be that black and white for some. Rather, you’ll need to strike a balance between speed, coverage, price and devices.

To help you along with delving into the details, see the detailed reviews on each of the providers below.

In each review, I cover 4G plans, 4G speed, 4G coverage and 4G devices in greater detail:

 

AT&T 4G Review

 

Clear 4G Review

 

Sprint 4G Review

 

T-Mobile 4G Review 

 

Verizon 4G Review

Who’s your mobile broadband provider? How’ve they been treating you?

email

7 Comments

  1. Randy says:


    On t-mobile’s network here in minneapolis I recently went from sub-standard speeds of 0.9Mbps to 5 to 6Mbps down and 1 to 3Mbps up in the last 2 months, quite a welcome change.


  2. blazinshotguns says:


    You say that Verizon 4g is the fastest but AT&T is hdpa+ which is 3.5g AT&T has not released 4g yet but it’s going to be faster then Verizon 4g


  3. Patrick says:


    I’ve been on Clear’s $45/mo + $5/mo modem rental 4G only service for nearly a year now, and the service has been stellar wherever I’m able to get on. The coverage has been decent in most places, with some very infrequent frustrating dead zones. All-in-all, I am very pleased. Last month, I consumed 80gb of data. If I were on Verizon, that would have cost me $780! On AT&T, it would cost $800!!!! If you are a power user like myself, and consume 1-3GB per day, Clear or Sprint are the only game in town worth considering.


  4. J says:


    I am looking for 4g coverage i live in austin tx an will use it to play games. I dont want to get data capped an dont want extra charges. What are my choices thanks


  5. Shirley says:


    Can someone offer me some advice, please? I am retired, in my sixties, and about to move into a motor home. I plan to spend the next 10 years traveling throughout the US, but will primarily be in the western US (CA, OR, WA, with occasional sidetrips to ID, AZ, CO, and UT.
    My only internet access will be on my laptop, with internet connection via my cell phone. I’m not into online video games or downloading music & movies. Primarily I surf the net about 3 hours per day average. I’ll be in large cities on occassion, but usually in outlying areas. Got any advice on which company I should go with?


    • Adam says:


      You need to buy Nokia e 71 and get unlimited data from att for 15 bux. This plan is only for non smart phone. Use e 71 to hook up ur laptop. You r good to go.


  6. qolspony says:


    I had clear wireless when I was in NYC last year for $60 a month. I had it for three months. I’m now have T-mobile, but my location has changed. I’m in Fayetteville, NC.

    Clear is the clear winner with speed. But it lacks security, which is why I’m apprehensive in it being a good choice.

    T-mobile on the other hand has great security and lack speed. It’s plans are also very confusing. The post paid offers unlimited at a great reduce speed. The reduce speed does not allow you to watch videos. It is so bad, it almost worth not having.

    But the most troubling part is the fact it charges you for not using the service. For instance, if you want to put the service on hold, it charges you $10. This is how they are able to make money off of inactive customers. It’s what you call a loop hole. The prepaid is a better choice for this reason, just make sure you don’t watch videos on this connection.

    But between the two, T-mobile edges out, because, having a secured connection is absolutely necessary for surfing the internet. Plus, Clear does not offer an internet option in Fayetteville, NC. It’s too second tier for them.


Leave a Courteous Reply to Randy